Outreach Marketing Agency vs Hiring In-House: Which Should You Choose?

When you're ready to scale your outbound efforts—be it through cold email, LinkedIn outreach, or full-funnel multichannel campaigns—one of the first decisions you'll face is this:

Should you build an in-house outreach team or partner with an outreach marketing agency?

At first, it might seem like a cost-based decision. But the reality goes deeper—this is a strategic choice that affects your time to market, growth velocity, risk exposure, and return on investment (ROI). In this guide, we break down the pros, cons, and key considerations to help you make the right call.

The Hidden Costs of Building an In-House Outreach Team

Many companies assume that hiring a sales rep will be enough to kickstart outbound. But outbound done well is a full-stack operation—it involves not just conversations, but systems, copy, tech, data, and constant iteration.

What You’re Actually Signing Up For

Hiring in-house for outbound isn’t just about bringing in a sales rep. In reality, you’re building a compact growth team from the ground up. You’ll need someone to manage outreach and lead conversations (a BDR or SDR), a technical expert to handle deliverability, CRM integration, scraping tools, and automation workflows, and a strategist to shape messaging, segment audiences, and continuously optimise performance. As your efforts scale, you’ll also need someone to train, manage, and retain the team.

The costs add up fast. A mid-level BDR typically earns £35,000–£45,000 per year. A technical specialist for outreach automation and tooling might add another £40,000–£55,000. Then there’s the monthly cost of your software stack—CRM systems, email warmup tools, scraping platforms—which can range from £500 to £2,000. Factor in employer NI, benefits, HR support, and training, and your total overhead increases by another 20–30%.

And all of this investment happens before you’ve even generated your first qualified lead. Building in-house can offer control and long-term value—but it’s a slow, resource-intensive route that demands both time and capital.

‍

Mistakes Can Be Costly

Outbound has a steep learning curve. One misstep—like improper email warmup, sending without targeting, or failing to personalise—can sink your campaigns and get your domain blacklisted.

For startups and scaling companies, this can mean spending months (and thousands of pounds) trying to “figure it out” only to hit a wall and start from scratch with an agency later.

Why Businesses Partner with Outreach Marketing Agencies

A top-tier outreach marketing agency brings more than just execution—they bring infrastructure, experience, and proven systems that are designed to scale from day one.

Deep Expertise, Pre-Packaged

Rather than hiring and training multiple team members, agencies provide a plug-and-play growth engine. This often includes:

• Strategists who understand B2B buyer psychology and messaging frameworks
  
  
• Cold outreach copywriters who know how to grab attention in noisy inboxes
  
  
• Tech specialists who handle automation, deliverability, and reporting
  
  
• Dedicated account managers who test, refine, and scale your campaigns
  
  

Because outreach is their sole focus, agencies operate with precision and speed that’s hard to replicate internally.

Speed to Execution

In-house teams often take 1–3 months to recruit, onboard, and operationalise. In contrast, an agency can go live in 1–2 weeks—with your ICP defined, messaging crafted, and tech stack already in place.

This is especially valuable if you're:

• Launching into new markets
  
  
• Running time-sensitive product or campaign tests
  
  
• Looking for quick wins to prove outbound ROI
  
  

Lower Upfront Costs

Despite what many assume, working with an agency often costs less in the short term. While in-house teams require £5,000–£10,000/month once you factor in salaries and tools, many agencies charge a flat monthly fee—typically between £2,000–£4,000.

That fee covers everything: tools, talent, campaign management, and results tracking. It’s a low-risk way to test outbound before committing to the cost of building internally.

When Does In-House Outreach Make Sense?

Agencies aren’t a one-size-fits-all solution. There are situations where building in-house is the better move.

1. You’re Already a Sales-Driven Organisation

Companies with established outbound cultures—like SaaS firms or recruitment agencies—often have the internal infrastructure, processes, and tech stack to support in-house outreach. For them, adding more outbound reps is an extension of what’s already working.

2. You Require High Brand Control or Niche Messaging

If your industry involves compliance-heavy messaging, sensitive data, or nuanced language that’s hard to brief externally, managing things in-house can give you greater control over tone, positioning, and brand representation.

3. You’re Playing the Long Game

Hiring in-house pays off when you’re committed to building a long-term growth engine. This includes investing in team development, setting up processes, and continually training staff. If you’re looking for control and internal knowledge retention, this route can work—just expect a longer ramp-up.

Understanding ROI: Outreach Marketing Agency vs In-House

When it comes to outbound, ROI isn’t just about how much you spend—it’s about how quickly you can turn that investment into revenue. Whether you choose an in-house team or an outreach marketing agency, the core question is the same:

What’s the cost of acquiring a client vs. the revenue that client generates?

The Agency ROI Equation

Let’s say you hire an outreach marketing agency at a flat rate of £2,000/month. If your average client is worth £1,000/month, then closing just two new clients each month means you’re already breaking even—anything beyond that is pure profit.

In most cases, a good agency will not only help you reach that breakeven point quickly, but will also scale campaigns over time to improve cost-per-acquisition and increase volume. That’s where the compound ROI kicks in.

Now compare that to the in-house route:

• Hiring a BDR, marketer, and buying the right tools will likely set you back £5,000–£10,000+ per month once salaries, NI, benefits, and overheads are factored in.
  
  
• You’ll also need to consider the time cost—in-house teams typically take 2–3 months to ramp up and become productive.
  
  
• During that time, you’re spending money without generating pipeline, delaying your ROI.
  
  

So while an agency may seem like a higher per-month cost on paper, it’s often faster to deliver actual returns, with fewer sunk costs upfront.

When Agency Outreach Doesn’t Make Sense

Not every business will see strong returns from agency-led outreach—especially those with low average deal values. If your product or service sells for £20–£50/month, then the economics become harder to justify.

At that pricing tier, you’d need to generate 40–100+ new customers per month just to break even. That’s achievable in high-volume SaaS or eCommerce—but usually through ads, SEO, or product-led growth, not cold outreach.

However, there are exceptions:

• Low-ticket SaaS with high LTV (Lifetime Value): If you have strong retention and upsell potential, outbound may still make sense.
  
  
• Freemium or trials with enterprise upsell paths: Outreach can be used to target decision-makers for larger deals.
  
  
• Partnerships and channel sales: Agencies can help open doors to strategic partners that lead to broader revenue opportunities.
  
  

Best Use Cases for Agency Outreach

Outreach marketing agencies deliver the strongest ROI when you're selling:

• High-ticket services, such as consulting, marketing, and software development.
  
  
• Enterprise SaaS with average contract values over £5,000/year
  
  
• Niche B2B products where each deal has a long lifecycle and high retention
  
  
• Offers with complex decision-makers, where cold outreach can cut through gatekeepers
  
  

In these cases, the cost of acquiring a single high-value client is far outweighed by the long-term revenue they bring in—making outreach one of the most efficient acquisition channels available.

‍

Side-by-Side Comparison

Criteria

Outreach Agency

In-House Team

Speed to Launch

1–2 weeks

1–3 months

Initial Cost

£2,000–£4,000/month

£5,000–£10,000+/month

Expertise

Built-in specialists

Requires hiring and training

Control

Medium (collaborative approach)

High (but resource-heavy)

Scalability

Easy to scale up/down

Slower, tied to internal resources

Best For

B2B firms needing fast results

Sales-led orgs with time & budget

Final Thoughts: In House or Out?

If you're a growing B2B company looking to test or scale outbound fast—without building an entire team—partnering with an outreach marketing agency is often the most efficient route.

If, however, you have the internal sales infrastructure, budget, and time to invest in a long-term strategy, building in-house may offer more control and internal ownership over time.

‍

Ready to Launch Without the Headaches?

We help B2B companies generate high-quality leads through done-for-you LinkedIn and email outreach. From messaging to automation, we handle the hard stuff—so you can focus on closing deals.

🚀 Book a call and see what’s possible for your outbound strategy.

‍